The Brisbane LMR Opportunity Brief
What Brisbane's More Homes, Sooner reform actually changes
We have been modelling Brisbane's More Homes, Sooner reform at individual site level. The first thing that stood out was the map.
This brief covers what changed in the assessment-pathway geography, the 400 metre transit test that drove the old map, how far the site-screening funnel narrows the universe, and how land assembly scales with project size. The commercial-feasibility results are a separate, later release.
Not subscribed yet? Get this by email and the results when they are ready.
Under Brisbane's current rules, the clean code-assessable pathway for a standard 3-storey Multiple dwelling project clusters in pockets around places such as New Farm, Woolloongabba, Stones Corner and other transit-served areas.
That pattern is not accidental. For the relevant LMR precinct, the current pathway effectively combines two geographic tests:
- Road reservesufficient road-reserve width
- Transita site within 400 metres walking distance of an eligible rail or busway station
So this is not a map of where 3-storey townhouses are allowed. It is a map of where the same townhouse product gets the cleaner code-assessment pathway rather than impact assessment.
Same product. Very different assessment geography.
Among the 44,238 sites where the current assessment pathway can be resolved, only 5,490 reach the clean code-assessable pathway, while 38,748 resolve to impact assessment.
Under More Homes, Sooner, the geography changes dramatically. Our model resolves 46,779 sites to the code-assessable pathway under the adopted reform. Of those, 38,230 sites specifically move from impact assessment under the current rules to code assessment under the reform.
That does not mean 38,230 sites have suddenly been rezoned. It does not mean townhouses were previously prohibited there. The product already existed. The LMR zoning already existed. What changes is the assessment pathway.
The road-width requirement turns out to be relatively minor compared with the transit test. Among sites failing one of the two tests:
- 29,466sites passed the road-width test but failed transit
- 511sites passed transit but failed the road-width test
- 6,234sites failed both conditions
So the transit condition was roughly 58 times more prevalent as the sole constraint than road width. That explains why the old clean pathway follows rail and busway catchments so closely.
Outside those pockets, essentially the same 3-storey product often moved into impact assessment.
A cleaner planning pathway is useful. It still does not tell you whether the townhouse product actually fits the site.
We screened the reform-affected sites against the geometry of Brisbane's established 3-storey townhouse product, including frontage, depth, access and layouts observed in completed projects. The current funnel is:
- 47,426 relevant LMR sites
- 38,230 shift from impact to code
- 16,491 physically clean or plausible sites
- 15,831 physically plausible, constraint-screened candidates
That is where a zoning map stops being enough.
Planning permission, physical development capacity and commercial feasibility are different things.
- 21%of 2 to 4 dwelling schemes involved multiple properties
- 36%of 5 to 9 dwelling schemes
- 56%of 10 to 19 dwelling schemes
- 60%of 20 or more dwelling schemes
Small schemes are usually a one-property redevelopment problem. By 10 to 19 dwellings, multi-property assembly becomes the majority pattern.
That matters because the acquisition problem changes with project scale. More owners means more control risk, greater exposure to holdouts, more time spent assembling the site and often a different acquisition strategy.
Section 5
The next cut is economics
A developer ultimately asks a different question from a planning map:
If I bought this site today, what is the highest-value product I could actually build, and what would the land be worth to me?
That requires combining:
- planning controls
- parcel geometry
- existing improvements
- achievable end values
- construction costs
- finance
- selling costs
- required return
- the value of the property already sitting on the site
The key comparison is the residual land value of the redevelopment against the value of the existing property. That is where planning reform turns into land economics.
We are now running that screen across the candidate universe. The next release will answer the question that matters most: which sites actually stack up? We will send subscribers the commercial-feasibility results when the analysis is complete.
Regards,
Steve Malcolm
Centrance
Development intelligence for Brisbane and South East Queensland